The Political Mind
The science and psychology of politics
Navigation
  • About
  • Mind&Politics
  • G Scott Blakley
  • I. A. Grea
You are here: Home › Commentary › The Left Side of Conservative
← Wealth over Wages: Tax Fairness and the Romney Return
Bored With Muddling Through →

The Left Side of Conservative

January 25, 2012 | Filed under: Commentary and tagged with: David Brooks, government assistance, work ethic

David Brooks, as usual, writes an interesting column, this one on Free Market Socialism.It’s clear why true conservatives look somewhat askance at Mr. Brooks. Viewing it in Lakoffian terms, we see Mr. Brooks straddling the divide between the conservative strict father methaphor and the liberal nurturant parent one. The column praises its subject, Maddie Parlier in “worthy person” terms, practicing the virtues that come from a conservative upbringing where obedience leads to self-discipline leads to success in a competitive world. Parlier has a good attitude and hustle, and a good work ethic.

The conservative mantra, as described by George Lakoff, or by Jonathan Haidt, or by others, is that those who succeed do so because they deserve success; those who deserve success end up succeeding. Good parenting, as Mr. Brooks described in his previous article on Mitt Romney, gives children the advantage they need to succeed.

But Maddie Parlier did not benefit from strong parenting, yet she has the right attitudes. Taking a nurturant parent view of life, Mr. Brooks has sympathy for Ms. Parlier; and as a liberal would, believes the government could do something to give her the opportunity she needs and deserves; and in doing so would strengthen the nation.

In an earlier column, Mr. Brooks attributed the success of the United States and of Germany to good habits nurtured by the culture and society. In this column, though, Mr. Brooks recognizes that success comes from an interplay of economic forces and social forces; economic forces require more skills to compete than Maddie Parlier has been able to acquire; social forces, a difficult upbringing and single parenthood, makes it more difficult for her to acquire those skills.

While conservative commentators generally decry the government’s involvement in society as destined to failure, Mr. Brooks, in a rather liberal swag, advocates government helping provide programs for job training, child care options, and better early childhood education, while at the same time advocating policies appealing to conservatives, cutting corporate tax rates, simplifying the tax code, streamlining regulations, and balancing the budget.

Decrying what might be called the stupidity of the Republicans (more capitalism, fewer taxes!) and the Democrats (tax the rich!), Mr. Brooks find an intersection between what they should be for, and which would benefit the country if we could get over our shouting matches.

Share this:

  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)

Related

Did you like this article? Share it with your friends!

Tweet

Written by Jacob Jefferson Jakes

← Wealth over Wages: Tax Fairness and the Romney Return
Bored With Muddling Through →

RSS Jonathan Haidt

  • Why The Righteous Mind may be the best common reading for incoming college students February 19, 2017 Jonathan Haidt

RSS George Lakoff

RSS Corey Robin

Jacob Jefferson Jakes

The Political Mind

  • View Jacob-Jefferson-Jakes-127488407357719’s profile on Facebook
  • View JacobJJakes’s profile on Twitter
  • View 118350928673473455810’s profile on Google+

Mind&Politics

  • View mindandpolitics’s profile on Facebook
  • View mindandpolitics’s profile on Twitter
  • View 107647165319384338834’s profile on Google+

Recent Posts

  • The Truth Behind the Curtain: Ken Ham, Antonin Scalia, and Milton Friedman find it February 20, 2017
  • “I Support Trump” July 31, 2016
  • GOP Media Warfare, Hierarchy, and Agriculture November 28, 2015
  • To the Heart of an Idea, Conservative and Liberal October 25, 2015
  • State Sovereignty and Constitutionally-limited Government September 7, 2015
  • “…of the United States…”: Creating a Nation July 27, 2014
  • I Would Not Throw the Fat Man Off the Bridge and onto the Trolley Tracks July 13, 2014
  • Shit Happens and Big Data July 12, 2014
  • Wittgenstein, Identity-Protection Cognition, and Understanding Rather than Persuading June 1, 2014
  • What if Piketty is Right? April 27, 2014

Recent Comments

  • gate.io on WSJ loves OWS
  • Sign Up for gate.io on Reciprocity, Deadbeats, and Banks
  • User Login on Taxes, Income, and Wealth
  • erc 1155 on What if Piketty is Right?
  • 交易所 on Wittgenstein, Identity-Protection Cognition, and Understanding Rather than Persuading
  • gate io on To the Heart of an Idea, Conservative and Liberal
  • แอ พ โซ เชีย ล ยอด นิยม on Introverts and Presidential Candidates
  • Novedades de gate io on Medieval Mysteries… and the Deserving
  • gate io вывод on Conservative Small Government Socialism
  • revu com on Wealth over Wages: Tax Fairness and the Romney Return

Archives

Meta

  • Log in
  • Entries feed
  • Comments feed
  • WordPress.org

Categories

Tags

1% abortion Adam Smith anti-federalist Articles of Confederation Avi Tuschman conservatism conservative conservative boredom conservative enthusiasm constitution critical thinking Daniel Kahneman David Brooks democracy Elvin Lim federalist federal taxes gay rights George Lakoff hobby lobby income inequality Jonathan Haidt Joshua Greene karma liberal libertarians Mitt Romney moral politics Moral Tribes natural law Newt GIngrich Occupy Wall Street Patrick Allitt pro-life racism robert reich Steven Pinker strict father model tax policy tax quintiles Tea Party The Lovers Quarrel Thomas Pangle virtue of muddling through

© 2023 The Political Mind

Powered by Esplanade Theme by One Designs and WordPress